Only about 30% of part-time and full-time U.S. employees say they are engaged at work, the lowest level in more than a decade, according to an annual Gallup survey. Cultural historian Bob Batchelor, who has written extensively on workplace culture, argues the figure is evidence of a widespread leadership failure — a “leadership chasm” between what executives believe and what employees feel.
- Only about 30% of U.S. part-time and full-time employees say they are engaged at work, the lowest level in more than a decade, according to an annual Gallup survey.
- A 2026 study by the Center for Organizational Effectiveness, drawing on anonymized clinical conversations with workers at over 100,000 organizations employing 88 million people worldwide, identifies work-life balance, job-performance anxiety, and unclear objectives as the top three concerns impeding psychological safety globally.
- Only 46% of American workers report that they clearly know what their employers expect from them, down from 56% in 2020, the Center for Organizational Effectiveness found.
- The Center for Organizational Effectiveness report notes that work-life balance has displaced workplace trauma as the leading concern for U.S. employees, with chronic exhaustion now a hallmark of employment.
- Donald Thompson, managing director of the Center for Organizational Effectiveness, said psychological safety is built on “the daily realities of how people experience work” and does not exist in isolation.
The gap between how bosses see themselves and how workers experience them is no longer just a sitcom premise from “The Office,” but the central reason American workplaces are in trouble, wrote Bob Batchelor, an assistant professor of communication, media and culture at Coastal Carolina University, in an article published through United Press International and republished from The Conversation.
Batchelor writes that when more than two-thirds of the workforce is checked out, it’s evidence of a widespread leadership failure.
One reason why most workers aren’t engaged on the job has to do with their psychological safety, meaning whether they feel they can speak up, ask questions or admit mistakes without being punished. Batchelor has been tracking the gap between psychological safety as a stated value for employers and the lived reality of their employees for years.
Amy Edmondson, a leadership and management scholar, has pioneered research in this area, finding that teams with high levels of psychological safety outperform those that don’t.
The 2026 Psychological Safety Study released in March by the Center for Organizational Effectiveness, a consulting firm, took a different approach from typical workplace surveys. The study draws on anonymized clinical conversations with workers at over 100,000 companies, organizations and government agencies that employ 88 million people around the world. The data was drawn from what employees told licensed counselors in confidence.
The study identified the top three concerns impeding psychological safety globally: work-life balance when job demands consistently exceed the time and energy workers have; job-performance anxiety from trying to meet a supervisor’s vague or constantly changing expectations; and contending with unclear objectives.
Only 46% of American workers feel they clearly know what their employers expect from them, according to the Center for Organizational Effectiveness, down from 56% in 2020.
For American workers, being stretched thin has become the new normal. Work-life balance has displaced workplace trauma — harassment, violence or sustained high-stress environments — as the leading concern for U.S. employees. Chronic exhaustion is now a hallmark of employment, whether in an office or from home. Employee fears of seeing their jobs eliminated due to the rise of artificial intelligence or a weak economy are adding to a perception of imbalance.
The Center for Organizational Effectiveness report highlights distinct trends in different places. In France, the top workplace concern is a lack of room for professional development, with workdays kept short by strict labor laws limiting access to learning opportunities and career mobility. Unlike in the United States, work-life balance does not appear in France’s top three concerns. “American workers feel they cannot breathe. French workers feel overlooked and stagnant,” the report states.
A lack of clarity about how well they’re doing their jobs ranked as a top concern for workers in 11 countries including the Philippines, Vietnam, Brazil and Mexico.
Donald Thompson, managing director of the Center for Organizational Effectiveness and author of The Employee Engagement Handbook, said psychological safety “doesn’t exist in isolation” and is built on the daily realities of how people experience work. For employees to believe in their bosses, Thompson said, they need to see a leader respond with openness rather than defensiveness when a co-worker raises a tough question.