Caleb Suh drugged Jane Doe and forced her to miscarry.

Jane Doe was 19 years old and a second-year cadet at West Point when Suh, a cadet in the class below her, used deception to end her pregnancy. In his account to the federal court in Manhattan, Suh said Jane Doe wanted to carry the pregnancy and he did not. He impersonated her to open an online-pharmacy account, ordered abortion medication, obtained Xanax from a friend to use as a sedative, and deceived his girlfriend into drinking what she thought was a prenatal protein shake. He waited until she fell asleep, then administered the abortion medication orally and vaginally.

Jane Doe’s lawsuit, filed under the alias Jane Doe on Oct. 28 in a New York court and first reported by The New York Times, alleges that Suh left her alone and incapacitated and bleeding. It alleges that he ignored her attempts to reach him after she woke and returned to the pharmacy website while she was being treated, where he asked whether doctors might detect the pills. The complaint alleges that the medication caused her miscarriage and seeks unspecified damages. The drugging and the medication are in Suh’s own account to the judge. The pharmacy questions remain allegations in an untried civil case. Jane Doe called 911 and was hospitalized.

In June 2026, Suh pleaded guilty to the March 2022 assault. A guilty plea is the defendant’s admission of the charge in open court. The comparison that decides cases like this one is what was said at the first proceeding and what was said at the second. Assistant U.S. Attorney Marcia Cohen said in court that Suh had told a West Point investigator that the miscarriage was accidental and denied ordering abortion medication. West Point’s investigation produced a denial. The federal file now contains an admission of the same conduct four years later, from the same mouth.

West Point has not said what its investigation found or whether it made any finding. The public record does not say when the case reached the Manhattan U.S. Attorney’s Office or why the charge came in June 2026 rather than 2022. It does say that West Point told Cornell that Suh was in good academic standing and eligible to return. That was a statement about a transcript, not about the assault.

Every institution in this chain has an answer, and none of them answers the question that mattered. Cornell asked whether Suh had been found responsible for a disciplinary violation at a previous educational institution. An admissions office can verify findings; it cannot make one. Columbia’s Mailman School of Public Health, according to a person familiar with the matter who was not authorized to comment publicly, asks whether an applicant has ever been disciplined for student conduct violations or poor academic performance. It does not ask about criminal records at all. The federal government charged a man, he pleaded guilty, and sentencing is set for January. Each institution followed the rule in front of it. None had to know what the other rules missed.

Columbia can point to discretion and privacy. The report identifies no automatic-exclusion rule, and privacy law limits what Columbia can say. Cornell’s strongest defense is factual: it admitted Suh during the 2023-24 school year, before the federal plea, after West Point reported that he was in good academic standing and eligible to return. The report does not say Cornell knew Jane Doe’s allegations then. Nothing reported here shows that either school ordered concealment or falsified what the forms asked. A working lawyer could defend both positions.

Those defenses do not establish what Columbia knew. Suh began at Columbia in September, after his June plea. Whether Columbia knew of the plea when it admitted him remains unresolved. The application design made that ignorance easy to preserve.

The form made the decision easy to evade. Columbia asked about student conduct violations and poor academic performance. It did not ask about criminal records. According to the account from a person familiar with the matter, Suh’s Columbia application never mentioned disciplinary proceedings. The omission may have complied with the literal question. It still allowed the guilty plea to become a private checkbox. The institution that asked the least received the least.

Cornell’s question was broader in subject matter than Columbia’s but narrower in evidentiary reach. It asked whether Suh had been found responsible for a disciplinary violation at a previous educational institution. He answered “no,” and Cornell confirmed that he did. No disciplinary finding has been reported. Jane Doe reported the assault to West Point’s Criminal Investigation Division in May 2022.

Suh’s answer may have been literally accurate on Cornell’s form. The form nevertheless made another institution’s disciplinary silence dispositive. Whether Cornell knew the complaint before admission remains unresolved. That leaves the form’s design beyond dispute. If West Point imposed no finding, Cornell had no question requiring it to learn what Suh had done. An unadjudicated “no” is what a screening form was built to produce. Cornell asked the right question and pointed it at the wrong record.

A résumé does not carry intent. A sequence does. A sequence is how intent gets proved.

A March 2022 assault.

A May 2022 referral to Army investigators.

An investigation whose findings and outcome have not been disclosed.

A transfer to Cornell in the 2023-24 school year.

An application answering “no” to the disciplinary question.

A June 2026 guilty plea.

A September 2026 enrollment at Columbia’s Mailman School.

A continuance, requested by his lawyer, that moves sentencing to January so he can finish his Columbia semester.

The prosecution did not object.

The knowledge sits in the gap between the academy’s file and the university’s form. The most revealing document that crossed that gap came from the accused: his own denial to a West Point investigator, now in the federal file. The documents that should have traveled — a disciplinary finding, or a documented statement that none existed — did not. For four years, the chain asked the man at its center to carry the answer that institutions would not.

The government waited four years to charge Suh. It then did not oppose the defense request that moved sentencing to January so he could complete his Columbia semester, at the very institution whose application, according to the account from a person familiar with the matter, omitted any disciplinary proceedings. That is not the prosecutorial branch looking the way it is supposed to look.

By spring 2024, Cornell had recognized Suh for his writing and involved him with the Cornell Center for Health Equity, where he wrote about the intersection of emergency medicine, addiction, and public health and said he aimed to become a physician. He briefly worked at Cornell’s medical school. Cornell later credited him on a medical-journal report summarizing a 2025 conference on cardiopulmonary resuscitation. He graduated in 2026. Cornell’s files hold the transcript, the writing recognition, the center work, the medical-school job, and the journal byline. The federal file holds the guilty plea. What never crossed between those records was a disciplinary finding from West Point, or a documented account of what its investigation found.

Columbia admitted Suh after the June plea. Whether anyone involved in that admission decision knew of the plea remains unresolved. Columbia declined to comment, citing educational privacy laws, and his status at Columbia was unclear as of the report. The account of Columbia’s application comes from a person familiar with the matter, not a public document. Take it as reported, and the shape matches Cornell’s: Cornell’s answer is documented, while Columbia’s file, as described, is silent.

Nothing reported proves Suh was an incompetent researcher. The point is institutional. Columbia’s public-health program supplied the setting and professional access after the conviction. Cornell supplied the degree, research credit, and institutional network. Jane Doe’s public identity stops at an alias. Suh’s academic identity carries his name, academic record, and research credits. The institutional response produced degrees, research credits, and professional access.

Cornell is already fighting a public fight over its response to another Jane Doe’s assault allegations. That is a separate Jane Doe and a separate case. The overlap is institutional.

Cornell’s handling of misconduct complaints is also already in litigation. After a 2024 allegation that several men raped a woman at a fraternity house, a lawsuit charged that the university did too little after she reported it. A lawyer says the university’s health system failed the accuser, and Cornell now lets complainants opt out of a State Police referral. That switch decides whether a record leaves the building at all. Those matters do not establish what Cornell knew about Suh. They document the institutional machinery surrounding the question.

What the federal file did do was put Suh’s own denial to a West Point investigator into the record and leave it there. That is what a federal file is for, and it is the wrong instrument for the half of this case that is not the assault. A guilty plea answers the criminal charge. It does not adjudicate what West Point, Cornell, or Columbia knew or did.

No claim has been brought against any of those institutions. Jane Doe’s complaint names one defendant. The files that would show what West Point, Cornell, and Columbia knew sit in three institutions. Discovery in Jane Doe’s state-court action would require a plaintiff to win on the claims she pleaded before a judge orders anybody to produce anything. A Freedom of Information Act request to the Army would ask the same question.

The institutions did not have to conceal anything for this record to stay broken. Every rule in the chain asks another institution for its conclusion, and a conclusion is a document an institution can decline to produce. Cornell wanted to know whether West Point had found Suh responsible. West Point’s answer was that he was eligible to return, which answers a different question. The rules route the question through the applicant, the only person in the chain with a reason to misstate the answer.

An honest version of this would take one channel the country has never built. An institution that has investigated a violent act against a member of its community reports its finding, or the absence of a finding, to every school, employer, bar, and licensing body to which the person applies. That duty should be strongest at the United States Military Academy, where the government runs the school, prosecutes the case, and holds the file. The right record is West Point’s, and it needs a route that does not run through the man who wants it not to travel.

Remorse and rehabilitation remain relevant to sentencing. Suh told the court he was “deeply and immeasurably sorry for my actions and the pain that I have caused.” His lawyer said he had taken a three-month life-skills course for people charged with federal crimes. None of that erases what he admitted. Remorse and rehabilitation do not make the guilty plea disappear from the record.

The only answer that avoids repeating the evasion is a full accounting. Jane Doe’s lawsuit seeks damages from Suh. Columbia should disclose when it learned of the guilty plea, who decided to admit him, and what the public-health program was told. Cornell should disclose what it knew before admitting Suh, whether it sought the West Point investigation’s findings, and whether it reviewed his status after learning of the plea. The institutions may decide that a person with a conviction deserves education. They must make that decision with the conviction in hand, not behind a question written so another institution’s silence could answer it.

Caleb Suh drugged Jane Doe and forced her to miscarry. His own account supplied the method. Columbia admitted him after the guilty plea. Whether Columbia knew of that plea remains unresolved; the application form turned forced miscarriage into a question no one had to answer.

The sentence will reach the assault. It will not reach the investigation file, the transfer, or the two admissions files, because no claim has been made against any of them and no rule in this chain compels a record to travel from one institution to the next. Jane Doe’s complaint is the only document in the chain with any of this on its face. Everything after it is up to her lawyer.