TO: Medicaid Eligibility Offices, Arkansas and Indiana RE: Shelby N. and Fannie R. — 80-hour volunteer certifications FROM: Sterling A. Varice STATUS: CERTIFICATION WITHHELD
I convert 80 hours of a woman’s month into free labor at $0.00 an hour, and I hold the certificate that decides whether the State feeds her.
Fannie R. is a hand on the shower-chair line I own outside Fort Wayne, Indiana. Shelby N. is a welfare body on the cabinet line I own outside Fort Smith, Arkansas. Sterling Cabinetry is the name on the door. You own the cabinet in your kitchen. You own the chair in your mother’s bathroom. I keep their labor and the $0.63 it costs me to mail a sheet.
The Editorial Board’s “Medicaid Work Requirements on the Ballot” in The Wall Street Journal says the requirement is meant to correct incentives against work, and that healthy, working-age adults can keep Medicaid by working or volunteering 80 hours a month, with exemptions for pregnancy, recent birth, parents of children under 14, cancer, and medical frailty. I agree with enforcement. Maintenance should produce something. I don’t classify either of them as medically frail. Your taxes cover the State’s share of their cards. Your cabinet arrives on schedule and the chair goes in on schedule, and you’re welcome for both. God bless the certificate.
Let me put the form where you can see it. We can get this right together.
Why does she volunteer? Because 80 hours preserve her coverage. Why do the hours land on my line? Because I put them there. Why is the wage $0.00? Because employee status would put workers’ compensation coverage on my books. I classify the hours as volunteer service. You’re counting the way I count now. The State feeds her, I keep the 80 hours, and you pay for both ends. There is nothing in the form for her.
The form asks for 80 hours a month. I schedule 80. I pay $0 an hour and record volunteer service. That’s the euphemism. A volunteer, by which I mean a woman whose right knee buckles while she hangs the cabinet in your kitchen. I prefer volunteer service because a wage on a page makes clients ask questions.
At month-end, Shelby asks me to mail her sheet. Processing and mailing Shelby’s monthly sheet costs $0.63. Keeping it in my drawer costs $0. Shelby’s output had fallen below the postage.
I keep the $0.63.
Her Medicaid card goes dark because my certificate never reaches the State. She postpones the orthopedic visit because there’s no wage from me, no insurance from me, and no Medicaid to pay for the knee. The cabinet leaves for your kitchen. The $0.63 is too small to itemize.
You mean well. I know you do. That’s why I’m being kind enough to correct your instinct: Shelby’s knee isn’t a production cost. Let me teach you to stop counting it. I’m telling you this for your own good.
Now take a different state and a different product, and watch the same arithmetic run. Fannie’s line is outside Fort Wayne, Indiana, and I mail her file every month, because while she produces, the State feeds her and I keep the hours. Her right arm hangs beside her. She reaches across her chest for the rail and misses. The next client waits in the hallway. I schedule the next lift anyway. Her file is worth the $0.63 because her shoulder gets treated and the shoulder hangs your mother’s chair. Shelby’s file was worth less than the postage.
The knee is the example. Here’s the law.
This isn’t relief policy. It’s the Production Certificate: aid survives only while a productive employer certifies the recipient’s use. You don’t fund Shelby because she needs care. You fund the certificate because I need the hours. My desk holds the certificate. Her card carries the loss.
The pedigree is old. The labourer is worthy of his hire (Luke 10:7), and I agree with the verse. I improve the bargain. I certify Shelby’s 80 hours. The State verifies them. Federal-state Medicaid money follows the certification. I don’t send the certificate. Shelby’s card goes dark. The cabinet leaves for your kitchen. You pay the tax that funds the State’s share. I keep the line.
Let the old record speak. Cato was the slaveholder. He wrote:
“Sell the worn-out oxen, the blemished cattle, the blemished sheep, the wool, the hides, the old wagon, the old iron tools, the old slave, the sickly slave, and whatever else is superfluous.”
— Cato the Elder, De agri cultura 2.1
Cato filed the old slave and the sickly slave beside the old wagon and the worn-out oxen. The owner could sell the surplus. Until sale, the owner still fed the body. The law is public maintenance, private yield. All of the yield. None of the maintenance obligation. The State treated Fannie’s shoulder while she hung your mother’s chair; I kept the 80 hours. You paid for both ends. I don’t feed the ones I’ve finished with.
I am not new. I am older than the paperwork; this arrangement simply changed its vocabulary.
Excellent: every enrollee whose Medicaid renewal I prevent loses purchasing power. I left the sales forecast untouched. The order book is full.
I have eliminated those wages. Paid accessibility work leaves the market. I count only the certificates. My certificate book is full.
Shelby finishes 80 hours. Her right knee buckles when she lifts a cabinet door. She sits on an upturned crate until she can walk. The orthopedic appointment remains uncalled.
Fannie reaches for the rail once more. Her hand closes on air. When her shoulder fails the next inspection, I mark her attendance failed and remove her from the line.
Her coverage lapses.
I refill the slot.
Shelby’s hours are on a form. The form stays in my drawer.
I kept $0.63.
Sterling A. Varice holds the Hayek-Friedman Chair and serves as Dean of Instruction at Warden University’s College of Business and Economics in Richmond, Virginia. He is the author of three textbooks: Divine Mandates for Labor Utilization, Social Obligations for Profit Maximization, and Calibrated Deprivation: A Manager’s Guide to Employee Motivation.