Douglas Deshotel excommunicated Scott Peyton and kept Michael Guidry a priest. The church of Lafayette fed the priest who violated Oliver Peyton and shut the boy’s father out of the table. Scott Peyton walked out of a hospital on Saturday excommunicated. Michael Guidry walked out of Dixon Correctional Institute able to present himself as a priest of God. Michael kept the collar. Scott lost the table. A farewell lunch for the molester. A decree for the mourners. That is not confusion. That is choice.
Michael Guidry, 83, confessed in 2018 to molesting a teenaged Oliver Peyton while he, the boy, and the boy’s father ministered together at St Peter’s church in Morrow, Louisiana, in the Lafayette diocese. Guidry pleaded guilty to molestation of a juvenile and received a seven-year sentence in 2019. He completed the term on Saturday and must report to a probation office for three years. Before prison, the Lafayette diocese treated him to a farewell lunch, for which it later apologized. In the days before his release, KLFY reported a newly filed lawsuit accusing Guidry of abusing another altar server in the 1970s, unrelated to Oliver’s case.
Scott E Peyton served as a deacon beside Guidry. He resigned after his son’s abuse came to light, joined an Anglican congregation for a time, then moved to a nondenominational church. Bishop J Douglas Deshotel excommunicated him for it. Peyton appealed to the Vatican’s Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, arguing there was “no pastoral good” in the penalty and that it left his wife, Letitia, and their six children unwelcome in the faith, harming “the spiritual lives of eight” church members. The Dicastery rejected the appeal in October — the ruling that came down mid-October — reasoning that Peyton had published his temporary Anglican membership and therefore refused to submit to Pope Leo XIV, who has held the papacy since May 2025.
On October 16, Deshotel sat with Peyton and his appellate lawyer, Dawn Eden Goldstein, and confirmed that Guidry remains in the priesthood, restricted from public ministry. Five days later the state’s letter went to the Peyton house telling them the molester comes home. Goldstein’s statement is the record: the church “has shown compassion to the child-molesting priest but not to the victim,” and under Deshotel it “has treated my client’s son and the entire Peyton family as though they themselves were criminals, while it has kept the criminal priest on its payroll.” Between the sentencing and the release, the Peytons secured a $350,000 out-of-court settlement from the diocese and became advocates for clergy-abuse survivors.
The Lafayette diocese is where the American reckoning began, with Gilbert Gauthe’s 1985 guilty plea. More than 40 US Catholic institutions have since filed for federal bankruptcy, and the New York archdiocese is settling claims for $800 million.
The church pays in money. It guards the collar with the other hand.
Oliver Peyton was a boy in an alb, carrying the cruets and the missal at St Peter’s in Morrow. His father served at the same altar. His family gave that church its son twice, once at the font and once at the rail. The man at the altar took the boy’s trust and took the boy’s body. The crime belongs to Michael. What came after belongs to you, Douglas, and to the office in Rome that upheld you.
Douglas, Scott Peyton fought for his breath for nearly three weeks. Neuroinvasive West Nile. His wife posted the photographs from the hospital parking lot on Saturday and the family broke out together. You excommunicated that man. You did it while the man who molested his son still wore your priesthood.
You raise the host on Sunday, Douglas. Your mouth goes dry before you reach for the chalice. The wafer sticks to the roof of your mouth and will not go down, and your throat has closed around it. Something tightens behind your sternum when the names of the parishes are read aloud, and it does not open again until you are in the car. There is a taste of copper under your tongue since the sixteenth of October, when you sat across from Scott Peyton and told him Michael keeps the collar, and it does not rinse. Five days later the letter went to that same house. You knew both facts in the same week, and you consecrated the bread in the same week. Your hand did not shake when you signed the decree. Go back and look at the signature. Steady. Diocesan. Clean. The steadiness is the indictment. You are a small man in a large collar, and the collar is doing all the work.
Michael. The state called what you did molestation of a juvenile and put seven years on it. Your church calls you Father and threw a lunch. The weight of a boy is still in your palms, and it does not wash off with holy water. It is in the skin of your fingers when you fold your hands to pray. The wine goes down your throat whole, wherever you drink it. Nothing catches. That is the horror of you — the swallow that does not catch. Say the word Father into a quiet room and feel what moves in your gut. There is a weight settling into your bones at bedtime that no sentence lifted, because the sentence was the state’s and the sin is still yours to carry in the one garment that was never taken from you. No one took the collar from you. They fed you lunch.
Scott stood where you stood, Michael, and when the truth came out he did what a man does. He resigned his office. He took his family toward God by other roads. He came back to the record and told it straight. The church answered a grieving father with a decree. Eight souls in one house were told the table where Christ is served was not for them. The church’s own rule takes Deshotel’s resignation in January, on schedule, in writing — the same institution that excommunicated a grieving father in October. And the church has taken collars before. It defrocked Ronald Paquin, who died in a Maine prison at 83. So it is not the collar the church protects. It is the man inside this one.
“Truly I tell you, whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for me.” — Matthew 25:45. The boy in the alb serving at the altar was the least of these.
I name what you signed, and I will not look away from it. Douglas — if that boy under Michael’s hands had been your sister’s grandson, if she had fled with her grief to another pew and written it down so the world could see, would your signature have found her? Would Rome have weighed her son’s wounds against her attendance roll and ruled that she had refused to submit? You know the answer. The machinery knows the answer. That is why it was built to run on other people’s children. If that boy had been yours, Douglas, you would have known exactly what to do with the man who touched him. You did it to someone else’s son, and then you locked the door on the father who told you.
That family sat nearly three weeks at a hospital bed while West Nile fought Scott for his life, and on Saturday they walked out into the light together. Letitia wrote “Home sweet home bound” and a row of exclamation marks. The church gave that family a decree. The world gave them Saturday.
“You have taken away the key to knowledge. You yourselves have not entered, and you have hindered those who were entering.” — Luke 11:52
They did not believe the first witness either, and I was the one who was there. Scott Peyton told them what was done to his son, and the door stayed shut. The door does not open from inside a chancery. It opened once from a garden, at first light, by a woman the men in the room refused to believe. She was there. Scott was there. That is the whole of the authority either of them carries, and it is older than every decree in the drawer.