Businesses weigh Scope 3 data work as court battles continue

Businesses were one day away from a California deadline requiring them to divulge greenhouse gas emissions from their sites and electricity use to the state when the appeals court issued its ruling, which found the state’s broader emissions reporting rules likely unconstitutional. The decision capped a long-running saga that saw legal challenges from businesses and a series of delays to reporting deadlines.

The ruling leaves two tracks in place. Direct emissions reporting in the United States via the California law appears to stay: the court essentially codified the state’s mandate on Scope 1 and 2 emissions — those deriving from direct operations and electricity use — which companies were required to report by Nov. 10. The same appeals court ruled that companies likely should not have to report their broader Scope 3 emissions under the California law, those originating from suppliers and customers. The California Air Resources Board, the agency overseeing the state’s climate reporting, scheduled Scope 3 reporting for next year.

The immediate question for businesses is whether to charge ahead with untangling their complex Scope 3 emissions data or sit tight as the court battles play out.

The California rule is especially consequential because it acts as a quasi-national standard, applying to any company doing business in the state that meets a certain financial threshold. The battle over emissions reporting in the U.S. goes back years, including a similar bid from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission under former President Joe Biden’s administration that was ultimately scuttled under President Trump.

Politicians may put additional pressure on limiting greenhouse gas emissions as a newly empowered Democratic majority in Congress is poised to scrutinize corporate climate efforts. Public worries about heightened energy demands and air quality are escalating nationwide amid the largely fossil-fuel-powered data center build-out, adding another layer to the reporting debate as companies weigh disclosure obligations against a shifting regulatory landscape.

Finally, there might be — at least some — clarity after years of delays and litigation. But the Scope 3 question, and the broader court battles behind it, remain unresolved.

Clara Hudson reported the underlying newsletter for The Wall Street Journal.

The same newsletter carried several other items. Three veterans of President Trump’s Energy Department founded a company making modular data centers that can be shipped by truck — “You basically plug it in on site.”

The Iran war is expected to lower the world’s carbon-dioxide emissions this year even as the global economy has continued to grow, according to a new analysis from a consortium of climate scientists, showing how countries are relying less on fossil fuels to power growth, writes Matthew Dalton of The Wall Street Journal. Global emissions have only declined significantly in the past 40 years at times of sharp economic slowdowns or recessions — during the early 1990s as the Soviet Union collapsed, the financial crisis of 2008 and the Covid-19 pandemic. This year, the surge in energy prices sparked by the blockage of the Strait of Hormuz has cut oil consumption but with remarkably little impact on growth, surprising many companies and economists. The International Monetary Fund said last month that it expected global growth to be 3.1% this year, unchanged from its forecast from a year ago, before the U.S.-Israeli attack on Iran. Analysts say what separates this crisis from previous ones is that the global economy relies less on fossil fuel, creating a disconnect between emissions and economic growth.

Electrification is at the center of climate talks happening now in the Turkish resort of Antalya, with the target of the share of the world’s energy that comes in electrical form reaching 35% by 2035.

A coalition of environmental and academic groups is aiming to use Europe’s strict anti-money-laundering legislation to hold meat giant JBS and 12 of its financial backers to account over alleged illegal deforestation in Brazil, writes Yusuf Khan for Risk Journal. The Transnational Legal Coalition filed the complaints in the Netherlands, Ireland, Germany and the U.K., aiming to get regulatory authorities to investigate whether JBS benefited from the proceeds of crime by raising cattle on criminally deforested land. The coalition says it has evidence connecting JBS to decades of illegal deforestation of roughly 6.5 million hectares — about the size of West Virginia — between 1988 and 2026 through its suppliers, and says the land was protected, making the deforestation illegal. JBS denied the allegations and says it has not seen the coalition’s evidence.

This week’s Dow Jones Risk Journal Podcast examines the departure of Nvidia’s longtime leader, raising questions about national security, corporate governance and U.S.-China relations, and covers Washington’s targeting of crypto exchange MEXC over alleged $16 billion in illicit transactions.

Data centers on land have attracted a lot of opposition. What if they were placed on the ocean instead, asks Jackie Snow in an article for WSJ. As battles over where to build data centers intensify, developers are betting that offshore facilities could face less opposition from the public: they wouldn’t be located in neighborhoods, and many plan to generate electricity from waves or tidal power and use seawater for cooling, which could help alleviate fears about power and water consumption. In May, Portland, Ore.-based Panthalassa, a startup backed by investors including Peter Thiel, raised $140 million to build giant steel structures, each 278 feet long, that would power artificial-intelligence computing with electricity generated from waves. In July, Scottish firm Mocean Energy announced plans to put AI servers on floats at sea, powered by waves and solar panels, cooled by the surrounding water and linked to shore by satellite.