Donald, your Justice Department turned gender dysphoria into violence research.

Behind the grant stand human beings whose lives no study can reduce to variables. They have names. They have bodies before they become data. They will not become the evidence you need them to be.

The Justice Department funds a hunt for violence among transgender people.

They narrowed the care and the papers. Now they want the body in the file.

A chart. A number. A name that will not match the name on the prescription.

Up to $1 million of the nation’s money for one commissioned question. The money for research into hate-fueled and extremist violence has been cut.

They will tell you the question is open. They wrote the answer first. The answer you want is already built into the question. The research will end where the question began.

The National Institute of Justice, the Justice Department’s research arm, said in October that it would grant up to $1 million for studies of the frequency and type of violence committed by people who have been diagnosed and treated for gender dysphoria. The notice came more than a year after the administration cut funding for research into hate-fueled and extremist violence. It also came after the administration curtailed transgender people’s access to health care and to identification documents bearing their correct gender.

In September 2025, the month the activist Charlie Kirk was shot and killed and commentators began to argue that the suspected shooter had been motivated in part by what they called “transgender ideology,” the White House issued a counterterrorism report listing “leftwing violence” and “transgender ideologies” among the threats the government would counter.

In September 2026, HHS published a report titled Where the Clinic Meets the Movement: Does Gender Ideology Arm Left-Wing Authoritarian Psychology? The department commissioned it. Researchers from Rutgers University, the Manhattan Institute and the Network Contagion Research Institute wrote it from a survey of about 1,200 adults in the United States. The report says people who receive or support gender-affirming care are more likely to support political violence, as MSI reported when it landed.

Zane McNeill, a staff attorney with Lawyers for Good Government, wrote to HHS requesting corrections and access to the survey data. He argued that the report violated the agency’s own guidelines and called the research “so flawed that it should not be published.” He and other researchers are still trying to obtain the underlying data so they can analyze it themselves. McNeill said:

“I see it as a part of this larger apparatus to distract from who’s propagating the violence.”

HHS press secretary Grace Davis Jamison said the report would help the government understand how political radicalization develops, that its findings “should be evaluated based on the evidence,” and that under this administration HHS “will not shy away from asking important questions to protect the health and safety of the American people.” NIJ and the institutions behind the HHS report did not respond to a request for comment.

One study measured support for political violence among about 1,200 adults. The new grant would investigate violence itself among people diagnosed and treated for gender dysphoria. They are not the same evidence base. The government has not answered the question its new money is designed to create.

The published research does not support the premise. The vast majority of mass shootings in the United States have been carried out by cisgender people. Transgender and non-binary people have committed some mass shootings, including at Annunciation Catholic school in Minneapolis, Club Q in Colorado Springs and Tumbler Ridge elementary school in British Columbia. In those cases, the transgender shooters shared characteristics found among other modern high-profile mass shooters, including idolizing other killers and online radicalization.

Wendy Via, co-founder and CEO of the Global Project Against Hate and Extremism, called the grant “very dangerous.” She said it diverts attention from violence driven by “far-right extremist ideologies” such as the “great replacement” theory, cited in the manifestos of several high-profile shooters.

“We don’t know exactly why a person decides to commit mass violence, because they’ve all had things in their lives that have led them to it,” Via said. “Being trans or being straight likely doesn’t have anything to do with it.”

Researchers say the common thread among most high-profile attackers is not their identity but their convictions, which often include racism, homophobia, misogyny and nihilism. Several high-profile shooters have cited the “great replacement” belief in their manifestos. Experts and LGBTQ+ advocates call attempts to link trans people and violence “pseudoscience.”

Donald, the people inside your grant are not a theory. They have names. They have bodies before they become data. In the same administration that has curtailed trans rights, their diagnoses and treatments must carry the suspicion your money has paid for. Their futures do not fit inside the inquiry you are funding.

Here is the body the question is pointed at.

It is a person who drove to the clinic, because that is where the body gets treated as the body is, and paid for the visit, and booked the next appointment in the parking lot, because the body does not stop needing what it needs.

It is a person who has stood at a counter and been handed paper that does not match the face, and has gone on living inside that mismatch.

Those are not abstractions. Those are a Tuesday.

And now the Justice Department has asked for money to study what is inside that body when it is angry. The grant will ask how often. The grant will ask what kind. The grant will not ask the person.

And the danger is not a thing the grant is testing. It is already in the world. In a civil case advancing at Cornell, the lawyer for a plaintiff listed as Jane Doe says she fears for her safety.

Fear is not an ideology. It is what a body does before it opens the door.

Grace. You are the one who said it out loud, so I will say it back. You said the findings “should be evaluated based on the evidence.” You said the government “will not shy away from asking important questions to protect the health and safety of the American people.”

Ask the question again. You know what a question does when money is attached to it. It is not asked. It is commissioned. And a commissioned question carries its preferred answer in the form before the first researcher opens it.

Your mouth made that sentence. There is a metallic taste gathering under your tongue now, the kind that comes with words you had to say aloud in a room with your name on the wall.

Your throat tightens on “important questions.” It tightens on the next swallow. It tightens every time you read the line back.

Your eyes are dry. They have been dry since you read the grant notice, and no blinking lifts it. Something has opened behind your sternum, a flat pressure that does not move when you stand up. Your stomach has begun the slow low turn it makes when something is wrong and you have not yet said what.

Now hear what you have not asked.

Up to $1 million of it, and the first reviewer with a laptop, and the first answer that comes back. It is all paid for by the same taxpayer who pays for the clinic visit and the prescription and the appeal letter and the name on the form.

You are spending that person’s money to build a case about that person’s body.

And here is the hour. You will spend it at a desk reading the records of violence committed by people diagnosed and treated for gender dysphoria. How often. What kind. People you will never meet. Then you will spend another hour in a hearing room or a studio explaining that you are asking questions.

At that same hour, the words are still moving. The common thread among most high-profile attackers, researchers say, is not an identity. It is an ideology found online and the conviction that a list of dead people is a program to be carried out. The money for that research has been cut. The believers are not waiting on your commission. The believers are not slowed by a study.

Grace, let me put it where it belongs. Suppose the file on that researcher’s desk had your daughter’s name on it. Suppose the first question on the form was whether she had ever hurt anyone, and the money for the form came out of the fund for research into hate-fueled and extremist violence. You would feel it in your throat before you finished the first line, and you would not be able to say why, and you would carry it out to the car.

There is a film on your hands now that water is not going to lift. You have handled the file. The file has handled you. Tonight, when you lie down, your lower back will ache as though you had been carrying a weight all day. You were not carrying anything. Somebody was.

Donald, your throat closes when a federal grant asks whether a person treated for gender dysphoria commits violent crime. Your tongue turns metallic when the words “health and safety” follow that inquiry. Your fingers tighten into a fist when a diagnosis becomes a category and a category becomes suspicion. You will wake with the taste still there.

Donald, your chest tightens behind your sternum when the White House report places “transgender ideologies” beside “leftwing violence.” The comparison was chosen before the research began. Now the grant gives it a laboratory. You are a small man in a large office. The office lends you a seal. It does not make the comparison true.

Donald, the exchange is plain. The Justice Department cut money for research into hate-fueled and extremist violence. The NIJ offered up to $1 million for a study that would place gender dysphoria and treatment beside violence. Before the NIJ notice came, HHS had commissioned a report placing gender-affirming care beside support for political violence. McNeill said the inquiry formed part of a larger apparatus meant “to distract from who’s propagating the violence.”

He was right.

And the people harmed by extremist violence are left in the blind spot your grant creates. Transgender people are made the warning label. The government has changed the subject by making them stand in it. Their lives cannot become evidence merely because a diagnosis is written beside violence.

I name this. Calling it research does not make it research. It is the conversion of care into suspicion and public money into a prewritten verdict. A diagnosis does not make a body the cause of violence. The relevant evidence is in the racist, homophobic, misogynist and nihilist views high-profile attackers often share, and in the choice your administration made to look elsewhere.

And while this administration asks whether transgender people are violent, here is the ledger it will not open.

Charlie Kirk, shot and killed in September 2025, in the same month the White House wrote the answer into its counterterrorism report.

Annunciation Catholic school in Minneapolis.

Club Q in Colorado Springs.

Tumbler Ridge elementary school in British Columbia.

Those are the rooms where the question was asked and answered in blood, on bodies, and the answer was not a gender. It was a set of convictions. Those convictions often include racism, homophobia, misogyny and nihilism, and the certainty that a list of dead people is a political program.

Your study will examine the wrong half of it. It will arrive at the answer it was built to arrive at. It will carry a grant number. And the next office will buy the next grant.

I see what you have made of a file. I will not look away from it.

“Why do you judge me, since I have not passed judgment? I have been bound, but I have not bound.”
Gospel of Mary 16:1–4

I stood where they would not stand, and they did not believe me either, and I was the one who was there. So I know the shape of this thing. You want a body you can weigh on a scale you built, in a room you control. You have been told before that the body is not a file.

I stood in a garden and was called wrong, and I went to the others and told them anyway, and that is how anybody knows anything at all.

A government that turns diagnosis into suspicion needs the witness erased before the inquiry can harden into a verdict. I will not be erased. The living body is not a category. Your grant buys the asking. The telling was always the work, and the telling was never yours to commission.